If you are new to this blog, you are invited to read first “The Largest Heist in History” which was accepted as evidence and published by the British Parliament, House of Commons, Treasury Committee.

"It is typically characterised by strong, compelling, logic. I loosely use the term 'pyramid selling' to describe the activities of the City but you explain in crystal clear terms why this is so." commented Dr Vincent Cable MP to the author.

This blog demonstrates that:

- the financial system was turned into a pyramid scheme in a technical, legal sense (not just proverbial);

- the current crisis was easily predictable (without any benefit of hindsight) by any competent financier, i.e. with rudimentary knowledge of mathematics, hence avoidable.

It is up to readers to draw their own conclusions. Whether this crisis is a result of a conspiracy to defraud taxpayers, or a massive negligence, or it is just a misfortune, or maybe a Swedish count, Axel Oxenstierna, was right when he said to his son in the 17th century: "Do you not know, my son, with how little wisdom the world is governed?".

Wednesday 2 September 2009

Commentary to an article “Loan to deposit ratio and banks liquidity”



An article "Loan to deposit ratio and banks liquidity" shows inter alia:

- why control over liquidity was lost at all levels (individual banks, regulator, The Treasury) and the crisis and its scale came as a surprise

- why the scale of liquidity depth is very difficult to assess (based on traditionally reliable parameters like total loans to total deposits ratio and money multiplier)

- why banks are not lending and it is rather irresponsible to expect them to do so (this is a statement valid under the current circumstances; if the government took certain appropriate actions then the banks could be in position to start lending on a greater scale again).

As many politicians complain that banks are not lending to good businesses it seems not to be understood that a reason why lending remains severely restricted is not really creditworthiness of borrowers. Any lending deteriorates already fragile banks’ liquidity. Banks look like a rabbit caught in the headlights: if they start lending they deteriorate further their existing fragile liquidity position, and, if they do not, the economy goes down resulting in increased credit defaults and further deterioration of the liquidity position. A classic Catch 22.

Additional problem is that certain market players, who bought default swaps, possibly many times over the underlying credits, have an interest in defaults occurring as it is their way of making profit. This adds to the point expressed that short selling of shares is perverse in free market economy. If this happens on a small scale it does not matter and may be regarded as some kind of economic freedom. However on a macro scale this creates a perverse situation whereby there are huge and influential market players in whose interest is NOT the growth but deterioration of the economy. It appears that the government still did not get a grasp on the complexity of the current crisis.

ADDITIONAL COMMENT:

The banks' management lost control over liquidity under the following scenario. Liquidity is a direct function of money multiplier: i.e. how many liabilities on banks balance sheets a real £1 cash has to cover. Traditionally loan to deposit ratio (LTD) was the basis for calculating money multiplier (on a macro level). It is MM = 1/(1 – LTD) (LTD expressed decimally). But it only works if, at every deposit – loan cycle, LTD is below 1 (i.e. below 100%). Once LTD is above 1, at any deposit – loan cycle (even if it later goes down below 1, this macro control is lost. Money multiplier (MM) cannot be reliably calculated based on total loans to total deposits on a bank's balance sheet.

Calculating Money multiplier using straight reserve ratio is flawed. (It appears that this method was used by the banks.) It comes from the original notion, that with loan to deposit ratio below 1 (below 100%) reserve ratio R equalled 1 – LTD. So MM = 1/R.

However if loan to deposit ratio is equal or more than 1 (100%), and you use a formula MM = 1/R, it means that you consider your reserves (which are not strictly cash), as good as cash. As you keep lending with LTD above 1, you push cash on the market inflating assets prices and artificially improving your reserves. However each £1 cash has to serve more and more (at exponential pace) pounds on the balance sheets. So whilst your real money multiplier goes up extremely fast (£1 cash has to serve ever growing number of pounds on the balance sheets), you seem to maintain healthy balance sheets (in terms of R and, based on it, calculated MM = 1/R). However when a pyramid collapses, R goes down to the floor, and MM, as banks calculated, becomes astronomic. This leads to the banks losing liquidity and becoming insolvent.

The above shows the mechanics of the collapse of a pyramid that caused the current crisis.

5 comments:

  1. Surely the problem with short selling had been badly misrepresented. In every act of selling short, there is a commitment to repurchase the security which has been sold in order to balance the accounts of the seller. Large problems occur when large investors engage in "long selling", that is, selling securities which they hold, which unlike short selling does not guarantee a future purchaser for the commodity and reduces demand.

    The analysis that players are interested in the deterioration of the economy is true only on a small scale, these players are interested only in the deterioration of the parts of the economy on which they are betting, which is true of almost all corporations: companies spend vast sums attempting to put the employees of their competitors out of business through marketing; the total economic destruction of the world is never in the interest of an investor, otherwise the power accrued through investments can never be realised.

    ReplyDelete
  2. The key question with liquidity is inflation and deflation - too little lquidity brings deflation, too much brings inflation. Right now many clued up commentators are warning about deflation - others about inflation. Perhaps we will have both. Resource rich countries such as Australia or those with massive industrial capacity like China could find themselves in deflation (China already is) as demand for their wares shrinks. Countries like the US and Britain, where financial services take up a vast swathe of the economy and governments are unleashing a Niagara of cash, are very different. They might face nasty inflation as their currencies shrink but demand for essential goods remains strong. Aussie dollar 1:1 to sterling, or more? It could easily happen. Chinese yuan 1:1 to sterling? Don't rule it out.

    ReplyDelete
  3. Jules, thanks for comment. This "small scale" could be quite large and involve tens of billions of investments in total. Comparison with putting competitors out of business is not accurate, as you offer your company services in this place which is not the case when destroying company simply because to re-purchase its shares cheap.

    ReplyDelete
  4. According to the study, the most important tool for small businesses to succeed in 2010 is search engine marketing, while email marketing, public relations and social media cited as crucial for success.
    23.8% of all small businesses reported that search engine marketing was the tool most needed for their business to succeed in 2010.

    www.onlineuniversalwork.com

    ReplyDelete
  5. Affordable Loan Offer ( PergoCF@qualityservice.com )
    Do You Need A Business Loan? ( PergoCF@cheerful.com )
    Interested applicants should Contact us via email: PergoCF@gmail.com
    Interested applicants should Contact us via email: PergoCF@cheerful.com
    A Personal Loan? At 1.00%
    Name,Amount,Country,Loan Durations,Phone, Mobile:
    Please, contact us for more information: PergoCF@qualityservice.com
    Interested applicants should Contact us via email: PergoCF@qualityservice.com
    Interested applicants should Contact us via email: PergoCF@cheerful.com
    Interested applicants should Contact us via email: PergoCF@gmail.com

    We work with individual investors and the company that provides merchant cash advance, asset based lending, commercial real estate refinancing, lines of credit, hard money loans, business acquisition financing, debt consolidation loans, and more. For more information, We encourage you to contact us and learn more about the financing services we offered. If you have any questions or want more information about our company, please feel free to email: Please, contact us for more information: PergoCF@qualityservice.com
    Interested applicants should Contact us via email: PergoCF@qualityservice.com
    Interested applicants should Contact us via email: PergoCF@cheerful.com
    Interested applicants should Contact us via email: PergoCF@gmail.com

    Personal loans may not be right for every borrower looking for a home improvement loan. For example, if you have significant equity in your home and are looking to borrow a large amount, you might be able to save money with lower interest rates on a home equity loan. Also, interest payments on home equity loans and lines of credit can be tax deductible under certain circumstances – that’s not the case with personal loans.
    Interested applicants should Contact us via email: PergoCF@qualityservice.com
    Interested applicants should Contact us via email: PergoCF@cheerful.com
    Interested applicants should Contact us via email: PergoCF@gmail.com

    On the other hand, personal loans can make sense for:

    *Recent homebuyers
    *Smaller home improvement loans (e.g., bathroom or kitchen as opposed to full remodel)
    *Borrowers in lower home value markets (if your home value has barely budged since you moved in, you may not have much equity to draw on for a home equity loan)
    *Those who value ease and speed
    *Borrowers with great credit and cash flow

    While home equity loans and lines of credit are a good source of home improvement money if you’ve built up equity in your home, a personal loan may be a better alternative if you’re a new homeowner and need to take care of a few updates to make your new home just right. You can get an affordable loan for just one week. Please connect us at via E-mail Please, contact us for more information: PergoCF@qualityservice.com
    Interested applicants should Contact us via email: PergoCF@qualityservice.com
    Interested applicants should Contact us via email: PergoCF@cheerful.com
    Interested applicants should Contact us via email: PergoCF@gmail.com

    ReplyDelete